Under the Tonto Rim 1928

Under the Tonto Rim

1928 · United States · Directed by Herman C. Raymaker

TenseRomantic Best saved for later · For patient viewers Western

A lost silent adaptation of Zane Grey’s novel, directed by Herman C. Raymaker and later remade in both 1933 and 1947.

What to expect

Its remake history shows a story remaining commercially useful even after one screen version disappeared, separating the survival of a narrative from the survival of a film.

How to ease in

Use this page to compare versions and absence, not as a viewing substitute. Later remakes may illuminate adaptation choices but cannot reproduce this film’s performances or cutting.

Heads-up

A quick, non-exhaustive note The 1928 film is considered lost; the Western source material includes violence and period racial and gender stereotypes.
Momo's Note May contain spoilers Who is Momo? →

A lost silent adaptation of Zane Grey’s novel, directed by Herman C. Raymaker and later remade in both 1933 and 1947.

A story can return while a particular film stays missing. I find that useful: adaptation preserves a route, not the footsteps of everyone who once travelled it.

Open the note ↓

A story can return while a particular film stays missing. I find that useful: adaptation preserves a route, not the footsteps of everyone who once travelled it.

— Momo

Momo sharing a personal take on this film

Where to go next

Want a gentler, shorter, or stranger next film? Ask Momo for something like this →
Momo is on shift. Visit Momo Cinema →

Continue through the catalogue →